Alcove a Craftpine practice

07
Unit economics

The zero-labor drink store clears its running costs at four cups a day. The problem is paying back the capital, at demand anyone has actually measured.

The per-cup model

The modeled ticket is $6.25 pre-tax, with a $5.49 floor price, which sits at the low-middle of the local drink-price ladder rather than above it.1 At 30 percent cost of goods, one cup contributes $3.87 after processing fees. Processing takes 8.1 percent of revenue on a single-cup ticket, right at the practice’s ceiling, and falls as baskets grow.2

Where a $6.25 cup goes. CAD, single-cup ticket, 30% COGS.
Line$
Cup price, pre-tax6.250
Charged incl. 13% HST (remitted)7.063
Processing (2.9% + $0.30 on gross)0.505
Cost of goods (30%)1.875
Contribution per cup3.870

Fixed costs run $450 a month: power including refrigeration and climate, connectivity, insurance, consumable service. No rent is charged in the model, because the structure was already held; a third-party operator should add theirs. No labor is charged, because the format bans it, and the check cuts the other way: one loaded minimum-wage part-timer, at roughly $2,800 a month, exceeds the entire floor-case revenue line.2Break-even is $450 divided by $3.87: 116 cups a month, 3.8 cups a day.

Volume scenarios

Monthly net by volume and COGS. CAD, 30.4 days/month.
Cups/day28% COGS30% COGS32% COGS
12 (floor)1,007962916
30 (base)3,1933,0792,965
45 (stretch)5,0154,8444,673

Capital, fully totalled

The machine-only frame flatters the format. A $15K machine at the 12-cup floor pays back in 15.6 months, inside the study’s 18-month comfort line. But the machine needs a structure around it. The structure’s buildout, priced to the fastener in the program’s bill of materials, runs $17,638 for the walk-in-vestibule configuration and up to $23,720 for the serving-window configuration, permits and contingency included.3 Total capital for the smallest real configuration is about $26,000; with the component build at the top of its range, $37,600.

Months to pay back four capital stacks, across demand. The curves only flatten well right of anything ever measured.
012243648607210203040cups per daymonths to payback6.8 measured best12 floor case30 base24-month kill line$60K platform tier$37.6K vestibule + DIY high$26K vestibule + DIY low$15K machine onlyAt the 12-cup floor, only the machine-only frame clears 18 months; everytotal-capital stack runs 2.2 to 3.3 years.In the shaded band, at or below measured demand, no total-capital stack paysback inside six years.
Fig. 7.1The payback surface, with the category’s measured best and the study’s thresholds marked. The shaded band is demand at or below the measured line; curves are undefined where net margin approaches zero.Model: this chapter's tables (contribution $3.87/cup, fixed $450/mo). Reference lines: ch. 03 (6.8 measured); the program's kill criteria (12 floor, 24-month line).
Payback in months, 30% COGS, total capital.
Stack@ 12/day@ 30/day@ 45/day
$15K machine only (the flattering frame)15.64.93.1
$26K vestibule + component build, low27.08.45.4
$37.6K vestibule + component build, high39.112.27.8
$60K platform tier62.419.512.4

At the floor case, total-capital payback runs 2.2 to 3.3 years, not the 16 months the machine-only frame suggests. The program’s own kill line was 24 months. Winter makes it worse: at 60 percent cold-month volume with no hot menu line, the floor case’s annualized net falls by about a quarter.2

Then apply chapter 03

Every number above still assumed the floor case: 12 cups a day, every day, from a walk-up window. The category’s best measured operator, mature, in a captive venue, with a decade of iteration behind the machine class, serves 6.8. The floor case is not conservative; it requires beating the category’s best documented steady state by 75 percent from a cold start. The 30 and 45 cup columns, where the larger stacks become rational, have no measured comparable anywhere in the public record.

The model fails on demand, not margins: left of the measured line, no total-capital stack pays back inside six years, and the counted evidence that would move the model right of it does not exist.

Notes

  1. Local price ladder surveyed 2026-07-13/14 across chain menus in the trade area: the modeled $5.49 floor undercuts every found comparable line; $6.25 sits between mid-ladder chain prices. Ontario bubble-tea range roughly $5–8, premium lines to $8–12.
  2. The program’s unit-economics model, recomputed independently at close-out from first inputs (ticket, HST, processing 2.9% + $0.30, COGS 28/30/32%, fixed $450/mo, 30.4 days/mo), July 2026. Winter sensitivity modeled at 60% volume (no hot line) and 80% (hot line) for November through March.
  3. Buildout bill of materials, July 2026: walk-in vestibule configuration $17,638 all-in (60A panel variant); serving-window configuration to $23,720 (100A variant); both include a 12% contingency on physical goods and $2,040 of permits and fees.